Drive down almost any street off Rodi Road or Frankstown Road and count the front yards. There is a big maple in nearly every one, and they are all about the same size, and they are all about the same age.
That is not a coincidence, and it explains most of the tree work we do in Penn Hills.
One decision, sixty-five years ago
These plans filled in through the fifties and sixties. Builders put up the houses, poured the walks, and put a shade tree in each front yard, generally the same species, generally the same week. It was standard practice and there was nothing wrong with it at the time.
The species chosen was usually silver or Norway maple, for a straightforward reason: they grow fast. A builder selling a house wants a tree that looks like a tree in five years, not a white oak that will look like a stick until the buyer’s children are grown. Fast growth was the whole point.
Fast growth also means weaker wood, shorter useful life, and a mature size nobody was picturing. The tree that was proportionate to a new-built lot in 1958 is now forty feet wider than the lot, with a crown over the roof and roots under the walk.
And because they all went in together, they are all arriving at the same point together, up and down the same block.
What sixty-five years does to one of these
Four things turn up over and over when we look at these trees, and they are worth knowing about before someone tells you about them.
The union eight feet up. Many of these maples forked young into two co-dominant stems. Where those stems meet, bark often got trapped rather than wood knitting together, and that included bark works as a wedge that slowly pushes the union apart. Look up your trunk. If it splits into two roughly equal stems with a tight V rather than a rounded U, that is the feature to have looked at. When these fail, half the tree goes at once, and it goes toward whatever it was leaning over.
End weight over the roof. Sixty-five years of growth is mostly at the tips. The limbs reaching over the house are carrying more weight further out than they were designed around, and that leverage is what fails in a wind or under wet snow. It is also entirely fixable, which is the good news.
Deadwood, and a lot of it. As a maple this age matures the interior of the crown shades itself out and those branches die. They stay up there until a hard front knocks them loose, at which point they arrive on the driveway or the car. On a tree that has never been touched, clearing this alone can be most of a day.
Roots against the infrastructure. Surface roots lifting the front walk is the visible half. The half that matters more is what happened when somebody put in a new walk or widened a drive at some point and cut through major roots on one side. That damage does not show for years and then shows all at once, because the tree has been quietly less anchored on one side ever since.
The honest split: keep or remove
People expect a tree company to want the removal. Removals are bigger jobs. But we would rather prune your tree now and be the outfit you call in eight years than take a healthy tree out and never hear from you again.
Broadly, a tree is worth keeping when the trunk is sound, the union is acceptable or can be supported, and the problem is size and weight rather than structure. Reduction plus a deadwood pass handles that, and it is a fraction of the cost of removal and replacement. Our Penn Hills trimming page covers what those cuts actually involve.
It is worth removing when there is real decay in the trunk, when a union has already begun to split, when a major root system was severed years ago, or when the tree is simply in the wrong place and always will be, right up against a foundation with nowhere to go. In that case it is a removal, and putting it off usually costs more later because an emergency removal after it fails is more expensive than a planned one.
The thing nobody wants to hear is that topping is not a middle option. Cutting the stems back to stubs makes the tree throw a mass of weak shoots that are attached to nothing but a rotting stub, and in four years it is taller, denser and considerably more dangerous than before. We will not do it.
What replacing one actually looks like
If a tree does have to come out, the question that follows is what goes back, and this is where a street has a chance to avoid repeating the same mistake in another sixty years.
The first thing is not to plant in the same hole. A ground-out stump leaves a cavity full of decomposing wood chips, and chips pull nitrogen out of the soil as they break down, so a young tree planted into that struggles for years. Either we take the grindings out and backfill with topsoil, which we are happy to do if you say so up front, or you plant a few feet to one side and let the old root system rot down on its own. There is more on that on the stump grinding page.
The second is to look at the wires before choosing a species. If there is a service drop or a primary line over that yard, a tree that matures at sixty feet is a problem you are handing to whoever owns the house in 2060. Something that tops out around twenty-five feet keeps the whole issue away, and there are plenty that do well here.
Third, resist the fast-growing option, which is the exact reasoning that produced the current situation. Fast growth buys shade sooner and costs you wood strength, and these streets are the evidence. An oak takes longer to look like anything and then stands for two hundred years with far less trouble.
Lastly, give it room. The reason these maples are a problem is not really the species, it is that a tree with a forty-foot mature spread went into a spot with fifteen feet of clearance. Measure the distance to the house, the drive and the line before deciding what goes in.
Why the whole street matters
There is a wind consideration people miss. A row of similar trees along a street shelters itself. Each one takes some load off the next.
Start removing them one at a time and the survivors get exposed to wind they have not felt in sixty years, on root systems and crowns that developed in shelter. This is why a street that has lost two or three trees often loses another in the next big front, and everyone puts it down to bad luck.
It is not really bad luck. If several are coming out on your block, the ones staying are worth a reduction at the same time to bring their sail area down. That is a conversation worth having with the neighbors rather than each household solving it alone.
What to do about yours this fall
Stand at the curb and look at your tree properly, which most people have not done in years.
- Follow the trunk up. Does it fork into two equal stems? Is the join tight and V-shaped, with a seam running down from it?
- Look for dead branches in the crown, especially in the middle where it shades itself.
- Look at where the crown sits relative to the roof and the wires.
- Look at the base for mushrooms or conks, soft or missing bark, or a hollow sound when you knock. Fungal bodies at the base mean decay in the root collar and that is the one to take seriously.
- Look at the walk and drive for lifting, and try to remember whether either was replaced since the tree got big.
- Step back and compare the crown to the neighbors on either side. A tree noticeably thinner at the top than its siblings of the same age and species is telling you something, and dieback starting in the upper crown is usually the first honest sign of trouble at the roots.
The dormant season, roughly November through March, is the best window for the work. No leaves means we can see the structure, the cuts seal quickly once spring growth starts, and the ground is often firm enough that we are not marking the lawn. Booking in fall generally gets you a better slot than calling in January after something has already come down.
If you want a straight answer on your tree, call (412) 526-2028 or send a photo through the contact form, taken from far enough back to show the whole crown and the house. Chris will tell you whether it needs work, whether it needs to come out, or whether it is fine and you can stop worrying about it.