24/7 Emergency Tree Service · Pittsburgh, PA Fully Insured
Triple T Tree Care logo
(412) 526-2028
Skip to content

Why Two Trees the Same Size Are Not the Same Job

Two maples, both about sixty feet, both roughly the same trunk diameter. One of them is a half-day and the crew is home for lunch. The other one is two days, a crane, a traffic plan, and a conversation with the borough. Same tree, on paper.

Homeowners find that maddening, and I understand why. Every other trade seems to price by size. So here is the honest version of what actually drives a tree job, written so you can walk your own yard and read your own tree before you ever pick up the phone. There are no dollar figures in here, because the number depends entirely on the things below.

Can we get to it, and can the wood get out

This is the biggest one and almost nobody guesses it first.

A tree at the curb with the truck parked ten feet away is close to the easy end of this trade. Wood comes down, wood goes into the chipper, chips go in the truck, and the whole operation happens inside a thirty-foot circle. Nothing gets carried.

Now put that identical tree in a fenced back yard on a hillside street in Ross Township, with a four-foot gate and a set of steps. Nothing rolls back there. Every round of trunk wood, and some of those weigh what a refrigerator weighs, gets carried out by hand through that gate or winched. A chipper that does not fit through the gate means brush gets dragged the length of the property one armload at a time. The cutting takes the same two hours it always did. The hauling takes the rest of the day.

What we look for on the walk: how wide is the gate, is there a slope, are there steps, is there a fence we would need to pull a section from and reset, how far is it from the trunk to where a truck can legally sit, and can a chipper or a mini loader physically reach the back. Some Pittsburgh lots simply cannot take equipment, and that is where access-limited removals become their own kind of job.

What is sitting underneath it

A tree in the middle of an open lawn is the friendliest thing in this business, because we can drop wood and let it land. Every object under the canopy takes that option away.

When there is a shed, a fence, a pool, a deck, a greenhouse, a hot tub, a paver patio, or a neighbor’s garage under the drop zone, we stop dropping and start rigging. Rigging means the climber ties each piece off before cutting it, and a groundworker lowers it on a friction device to a chosen spot. It is precise and it is slow. A big limb that would take twenty seconds to cut and let fall takes several minutes to rig, cut, lower, untie, and clear.

The list of things people forget to mention: septic tanks and leach fields, which will not take the weight of a loaded truck and are invisible from the driveway. Buried propane. Sprinkler heads and irrigation lines. A well cap. A garden somebody has been building for fifteen years. Retaining walls, which around here are often older than the house and less enthusiastic about a falling log than they look.

Tell us about all of it. A septic field nobody mentioned is how a routine job turns into a bill from an excavator.

What the tree itself is doing

Here is where two same-size trees stop being the same job.

A sound tree with a straight stem, good branch structure, and live wood throughout can be climbed. A climber gets in, works from the top down, and the tree holds him and holds the rigging loads while he does it. That is the efficient version of this work.

A tree with defects cannot do that. Standing dead ash is the clearest example in Allegheny County right now. Emerald ash borer killed enormous numbers of them and dead ash decays fast and unevenly. The wood goes brittle, limbs snap off with no warning and no sound, and the top of a dead ash will not reliably hold a climber or a rigging load. Nobody responsible climbs one that has been dead a couple of years. It has to come out from a lift or a crane, which changes the whole plan.

Other things we read on the walk. A hollow or decayed trunk, sometimes obvious from a cavity and sometimes only apparent when we sound the stem with a mallet. A tree with a heavy lean, especially a lean toward the house, since the direction the wood wants to go and the direction it needs to go are now opposites and that gap has to be bought with rigging or machinery. Included bark in a main fork, which is a weak union that can tear apart under load. Fungal conks at the base, meaning root decay. Storm scars from earlier years. And multi-stem trees, which are several trees fighting over one root plate and have to be taken apart individually.

None of that shows up in a trunk measurement, and all of it changes the day. It is also why a dead tree removal is frequently more work than removing a live tree twice its size.

Rope and rigging, or bring the crane

This decision gets made on site, and it is the biggest single fork in how a job runs.

Rigging is the traditional method. A climber ascends, sets a rigging point in solid wood above the piece being cut, and the ground crew lowers each section. It needs no room for machinery, it works in tight back yards, and it depends completely on the tree being structurally sound enough to be climbed and loaded. When those conditions hold, rigging is often the right and least invasive answer.

A crane changes the geometry. Instead of lowering wood down through the tree, the crane picks each piece up and flies it out over whatever is in the way, setting it down in the driveway or straight into a truck. We reach for one when the tree is unsafe to climb, when it is directly over a roof and there is no path down through it, when the pieces are simply too heavy to rig safely, or when the tree is so large that a crane finishes in hours what climbing would take days to do.

The crane has its own requirements, which is why it is not automatically the answer. It needs a place to set up, level ground, and outrigger room. It needs a clear line to the tree, which means no wires crossing the swing path. Often it means the street for a few hours, and in some of these boroughs that is a permit and a couple of cones. Where a crane pick makes sense, it is usually both the safest option and the one that puts the least traffic across your lawn.

What you can read yourself: is the tree over the house, is there anywhere out front a large truck could set up, and is the tree healthy enough that a person could reasonably work inside it. If the answers are yes, no, and no, expect to hear the word crane.

Wires change everything and they are not negotiable

If there are conductors in or near the canopy, that is a category of its own.

The line running from the pole to your house, the service drop, is the one people misjudge most because it is low and familiar and it has been there their whole life. It is energized. Primary lines up on the poles are a different order of dangerous again. Neither one is something a homeowner touches, and neither is something an uninsured outfit should be free-handing near.

Work close to energized conductors requires trained crews, correct minimum approach distances, and in a lot of cases a utility drop where the power company de-energizes the line before anyone goes near it. Scheduling that is part of the job, and it is a real reason a job takes longer than the tree alone suggests. Sometimes we sequence a removal around a utility appointment, which means two visits rather than one.

None of this is us padding a schedule. Electrocution is one of the leading causes of death in tree work, and the deaths mostly involve people who thought the wire in question was harmless, or a phone line, or dead. Nobody on my crew guesses at a wire.

How finished do you want the yard

Two jobs on identical trees can end in completely different places, and this part is genuinely your call.

At the light end, we take the tree down, cut the trunk into rounds, and leave the wood stacked for you. Plenty of people burn firewood or have a use for it. You get the tree gone and you handle the wood on your own time.

In the middle, brush goes through the chipper and leaves, wood stays. Or the reverse for people who want the logs gone but plan to deal with the stump later.

At the full end, everything leaves. Brush chipped and hauled, all wood removed, stump ground below grade, chips from the grinding either hauled off or backfilled, and the area raked out so the lawn can recover. Stump grinding in particular is separate work with a separate machine, and whether that machine can reach the stump loops right back to the access question at the top of this article.

Where clearing multiple trees is involved, this decision compounds across every stem and becomes the single largest variable in how long we are on your property.

Walk your own yard before you call

You can size up most of this yourself in about five minutes, and the better your description, the more useful our answer is over the phone.

Stand where the tree is and ask: could a truck get within throwing distance of this trunk, or does everything have to be carried. What is under the canopy that would not survive a falling limb. Does the trunk look sound, or is there a cavity, a fungus shelf, a crack, or a lean that has changed. Is the tree alive all the way to the top, and if it is an ash, has it been dead a while. Are there wires in the picture anywhere. And when the wood is on the ground, how much of it do you want to still be there.

Take a few photos while you are out there. One from far enough back to show the whole tree with the house in frame for scale, one at the base, one looking straight up into the canopy, and one of the route from the street to the tree. That last one tells us more than the tree photo does, and almost nobody sends it.

When we come out for a large removal, that walk is exactly what we are doing, just with a mallet and a practiced eye for the defects. We will tell you which factors are driving your particular job and why, and if there is a cheaper way to get you what you need, we will say so. A tree job you understand is one you do not have to take on faith.

What people ask before we come out

Q. Why is your number different from the outfit that quoted me over the phone from a photo? Usually because one of us has accounted for the part that costs the day and the other has not. A photo shows a tree. It does not show the gate width, the septic lid, the slope, or the rot in the base. Numbers priced from a photo have a way of growing once the crew is standing in the yard.

Q. Is a dead tree cheaper to take down since it has no leaves? Almost always the opposite. Dead wood is unpredictable, frequently cannot be climbed, and often needs machinery that a healthy version of the same tree would not require. Less canopy to haul is real, and it rarely offsets the added risk and the added equipment.

Q. Can I save money by hauling the wood myself? Yes, and we are happy to leave it. Say so up front so we cut the rounds to a length you can actually move and stack them where you want them. Deciding after the fact means the wood is wherever it landed.

Q. Do I need to be home while you work? Not for the removal itself, though we like walking the property with you before we start so nothing gets assumed. If access runs through a locked gate or a garage, we do need that arranged in advance.

Q. How far ahead do you book? Ordinary removals go on the calendar in the normal way and we will give you a real window. Storm weeks fill up fast and genuine hazards jump the line, which occasionally means moving a routine job by a few days. We would rather tell you that than pretend otherwise.

If you have a tree you are wondering about, take the four photos, then call (412) 526-2028 and we will talk through what makes yours the job it is. You can also write it up here and attach them, and we will get you an up-front number without any mystery attached to it. Straight answers, professional equipment, one and done.